My HG eyeliner is MAC's Liquidlast Liner in Point Black. It has been the only eyeliner that I've tried that was truly waterproof, sweat proof, smudge proof, and long lasting....until now.
I was researching dupes for popular name brand products and I came across one that was too good to be true, a dupe for my prized $17.50 eyeliner for only $6.49. Last night, I went to my nearest Walgreens and purchased it, Milani Infinite Liquid Eyeliner in Black.
I tried it this morning and I was more than happy with it. It seems like it is the same formula as my Liquidlast! In some aspects, it's even better than Liquidlast. Milani Inifinite comes in a 5mL container whereas MAC Liquidlast comes in a 2.5mL container. Thats double the product for about 1/3 of the price! It isn't as gooey as Liquidlast either.
Left: Milani Infinite in the packaging.
Right: MAC Liquidlast and Milani Infinite comparison
Tip comparison
Left: MAC Liquidlast
Right: Milani Infinite
It looks as if the Milani tip is sharper but I just wiped off more product than I did from the MAC brush. They are almost if not, identical.
Swatch comparison
Top: MAC Liquidlast
Bottom: Milani Infinite
After rubbing with water.
Left: MAC Liquidlast
Right: Milani Infinite
After rubbing until my arm hurt.
Left: MAC Liquidlast
Right: Milani Infinite
(Sorry for the bad quality of the swatches. My camera died and I had to use my photobooth!)
Neither of them budged at all!
I have officially found my new HG eyeliner <3
-Miko^^
